25 Shocking Video Game Theories That Could Actually Be True

Posted by , Updated on April 22, 2024

The video game community is full of conjectures, with avid gamers steadily flooding online platforms and Reddit with varied understandings of their favorite games. Every now and then, though, a theory stands out that truly astonishes everyone. These hypotheses often strive to resolve unsolved enigmas within video games or even offer entirely new perspectives that were never before contemplated. Interested in uncovering these groundbreaking theories? If so, ready yourself and your controller. Here are 25 Staggering Video Game Theories That Could Very Well be True.



The Madden Curse

maddenSource: https://www.digitaltrends.com

The Madden Curse is a video gamers theory of theories. Originally starting out as a joke, it quickly grew to become a popular theory starting with Garrison Hearst on the cover of Madden 98′. Soon after he appeared on the cover, he broke his ankle. Of the 19 players featured on the game’s cover, 17 have suffered severe season-ending injuries soon after their video game’s release. Just a coincidence? That’s what EA Sports would like you to believe.


The Last of Us and Uncharted are in the same world.

uncharted last of usSource: https://www.reddit.com

Naughty Dog’s Uncharted series and The Last of Us are two of the most popular and famous video games in the modern age. Now, video gamers believe they’re both in the same world, but with The Last of Us occurring years, perhaps decades, after Uncharted. Some of the evidence includes an easter egg newspaper in Uncharted, pointing to a disease. They think that disease is the same one happening in The Last of Us. Now, if that is true, the main question remains, is Nathan Drake of the Uncharted series still alive? Or, could he blow everyone’s mind and show up in The Last of Us 2?


Every Call of Duty game is one long escort mission.

call of dutySource: https://www.reddit.com

This theory attends that every Call of Duty game is essentially one long escort mission, and the person they’re escorting around is you. Characters are always telling you what to do in the game. Enemies rarely shoot at you but shoot around you. Also, you’re never really leading anything but going from one place to the next with someone else in front of you.


Limbo is about a boy reliving traumatic memories.

limboSource: http://kotaku.com/

Not much information is provided about the world and game of Limbo. It’s essentially a dark adventure puzzle game loaded with symbolism. While there are plenty of theories about what the story is all about, one that sticks out the most is that the main character is reliving childhood traumatic memories, and the only way out of limbo is to deal with them.


Dark Origin of Minecraft

minecraftSource: http://kotaku.com

In a crazy scientific theory for the ages, one video gamer believes the world of Minecraft is actually a dead star, and the sun that orbits it is the Minecraft inhabitants’ old world. Still with us? Essentially, in the old world, they faced extinction from the dying star, so they blew up their old world to create a new star and moved to the dying star and began building on top of it to build a new inhabitable world. That’s why when you get to the very bottom of the Minecraft world you can’t go any further because it’s a dead star. So, when you look up at the sun orbiting the Minecraft world, you’re looking at your old home. We said it was crazy, right?


Mass Effect 3's hero is possessed by aliens.

mass effectSource: http://fantheories.wikia.com/wiki/Mass_Effect

*Spoiler Alert* Mass Effect is an epic video game trilogy about Shepard fighting aliens called Reapers. However, by the end of Mass Effect 3 you have three options: Control the Reapers, destroy the Reapers, or become the Reapers. It’s a no-win situation because in each situation Shepard dies. This fan theory suggests that these endings point to the Reapers spending the entire trilogy trying to indoctrinate Shepard to become a Reaper. At the end, the choice to become a Reaper is deemed a “good choice.”


Mario keeps Luigi from destroying the world.

mario-luigi-figures-funny-163157Source: https://www.reddit.com

For a long time, many have believed Mario to be the stronger and more capable hero of the two Mario brothers. However, this theory postulates that Luigi is much more powerful than he puts on. In fact, Luigi is so powerful that he could eventually destroy the world and that’s why he sticks with Mario wherever he goes, hoping that if he one day goes berzerk, Mario will be there to stop him.


Kirby is an apocalyptic world dweller.

KirbySource: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FZ-MjtUkIw

Kirby is a cute pink puffball, sucking up his enemies and turning them into stars. No one has ever equated his adorable world with a horrific post-apocalyptic nightmare, until now. One fan theory suggests that in Kirby 64, Kirby wanders a post-apocalyptic frozen Earth ruled by robots, fully intent on killing Kirby before he saves the day.


Majora's Mask is about the five stages of grief.

The_Legend_of_Zelda_Majora's_Mask.svgSource: http://www.gameskinny.com

The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask was a bizarre and controversial follow-up to the widely popular Nintendo 64 game, The Ocarina of Time. Regardless, it has a solid cult fanbase and many players have noticed the connection the story has with The Five Stages of Grief. Clock Town is denial, the Woodfall Temple is anger, Snowhead is bargaining, The Great Bay represents depression, and Ikana Valley represents acceptance.


The Pokemon War Theory

International_Pokémon_logoSource: http://kotaku.com

Where are all the parents and adults in the Pokemon world? The Pokemon War Theory explains that there must have been a devastating war, wiping out most of the adults and only leaving behind a select few. The rest are children, running about, trying to find monsters and making them fight each other.


Metal Gear Solid 3 never actually happened.

metal gear solidSource: http://twinfinite.net

Metal Gear Solid is another longstanding and popular tactical franchise that never seems to get old. Some gamers took notice when Metal Gear Solid 3 showed clues that everything in the game might not be what it seems. The theory suggests MGS3 starts right after Metal Gear Solid 2. In the opening of MGS3, Solid Snake is told to start the Virtuous Mission. He replies, “Virtual Mission?” Some believe this line was intentional and pointed to the fact that the whole game is actually Solid Snake in one big virtual reality.


Super Mario Smash Bros. Sad Backstory

smash brosSource: http://www.dorkly.com/post/71875/the-sad-secret-story-behind-every-smash-bros-game

While most people equate Super Mario Smash Bros. as a standard fighting game like Tekken or Street Fighter, there is surprisingly a lot more behind it. Starting with the first game all the way up to the latest installments, Smash Bros. secretly tells the story of creator Masahiro Sakurai growing up playing with Nintendo characters and then moving on to actually create the characters for them (Sakurai created Kirby). In Smash Bros., the Nintendo characters are toys controlled by the “Master Hand.” In the theory, each game reveals how Sakurai feels about making the games, and it’s surprisingly dark, including taboos, stress, and feeling torn in two.


Most Ubisoft games reside in the same universe.

UbisoftSource: https://www.reddit.com

Much like the Naughty Dog combined universe theory, one video gamer promotes an even bigger theory, that all major Ubisoft games reside in the same universe, including Assassin’s Creed, Far Cry, Ghost Recon, and Watch Dogs.


Squall doesn't make it out alive in Final Fantasy VIII.

final fantasy viiiSource: http://squallsdead.com/

*Spoiler Alert* This theory is essentially a “dream theory,” indicating that at the end of Disc 1 of Final Fantasy VIII when Squall is pierced with ice and falls, he dies. The rest of the game, Disc 2 and on, is a dream or vision of what Squall sees before he dies.


Pokemon Lavender Town Suicide

lavender townSource: http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Lavender_Town_Syndrome

While this is more of a myth and creepypasta than an actual theory, it’s worth mentioning. Also called “The Lavender Town Syndrome,” the Pokemon Lavender theory claims that a peak in children suicides on February 27th, 1996 in Japan happened after visiting Lavender Town in the Pokemon Red and Blue games on the Nintendo Gameboy.


Mario and his friends are just actors.

mario and friendsSource: https://www.reddit.com

With Mario and his friends ending up in a myriad of different game genres, including racing, sports, puzzle, and role-playing games, many have wondered how Mario and his friends can take on many roles. This theory suggests that Mario and his friends are just actors and all the games are merely stages they play on. This theory is also based on the fact that in Super Mario Bros. 3, the whole game looks like it’s on a stage. Look at the opening. The curtains even go up.


Portal companion cubes hold human remains.

portal 2Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5w6ieaTxGA

In Portal, the Companion Cubes act as pseudo-characters and helpers to get through the many mazes. One theory suggests that they have a dark history, including having dead human bodies inside them.


Silent Hill 2's Mary is in the trunk.

silent hill 2Source: http://silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=3976

Silent Hill is freaky enough without more people throwing theories on it. But here we are. In Silent Hill 2, James Sunderland’s wife writes to him before she dies of an illness, requesting he meet her at their special spot. However, the theory states that she never died of an illness and James murdered her and put her body in the trunk. She was in the car trunk the entire time.


In Max Payne 3, the ex-cop is a ghost.

max payne 3Source: http://maxpayne.wikia.com/wiki/Anders_Detling

*Spolier Alert* In Max Payne 3, Max is frequently visited by a fat ex-cop who has a wife and daughter. Many believe this character is actually a ghost, haunting Max of the life he could have had if his wife and daughter hadn’t died.


Animal Crossing is about a child-abducting cult.

animal crossingSource: http://www.gamesradar.com/animal-crossings-dark-side-revealed/

Just when you thought video game conspiracy theorists couldn’t make things any darker, they went and made Animal Crossing super creepy. This theory claims Animal Crossing is about human trafficking, making you an indentured servant, and brainwashing you into joining a creepy cult. Actually, now that we think about it, that makes a lot of sense.


The Skyrim Apocalypse Theory

skyrimSource: https://www.reddit.com

The land of Skyrim is a massive world full of mysteries and uncharted secrets. One specific mystery revolves around five bug jars scattered across Skyrim with different bugs inside and runes under each lid. Some have theorized if all bug jars are collected and the runes are deciphered, it’ll mean the total and utter annihilation of all mankind. So, do us all a favor and leave the bug jars alone.


Donkey Kong country is anti-American propaganda.

donkey kong countrySource: https://www.reddit.com/

Many know Donkey Kong as the villain stealing princesses and fighting Mario, but in Donkey Kong Country, he becomes the hero fighting his own villain: American imperialism. In this theory, Donkey Kong is on a Caribbean island trying to steal back the bananas that King K. Rool stole. During President Roosevelt’s time in office, the US helped big business take over the banana trade and allowed monopolies to thrive there. The theory speculates Donkey Kong is essentially fighting President Roosevelt. This connection, plus the fact that many of the villains are also dressed like American military grunts, and you have a very compelling argument.


Fallout 3 predicted Deepwater Horizon.

fallout 3Source: http://www.gamesradar.com

In the game Fallout 3, players can receive radio transmissions from various radio stations around the haggard, post-apocalyptic city of Washington D.C. Some of these transmissions are morris code. One theory claims to have interpreted the morris code, and one of them predicted the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.


*Spoiler Alert* Aeris wasn't supposed to die in Final Fantasy VII.

final fantasy viiSource: https://www.destructoid.com

No gamer wanted to see Aeris from Final Fantasy VII die (especially if they had built her up to be a powerful character). Some thought the death felt rushed and out of nowhere which lead to a prominent theory: Originally, Aeris was never meant to die. The theory claims the narrative never called for Aeris to die but was quickly put in to shake things up and create chaos. Another theory similar to this one states that Aeris was meant to die but was also meant to be resurrected later in the game but the creators decided against it.


Zelda: Breath of the Wild is Zelda 3 in the Hyrule Timeline

zeldaSource: http://www.geek.com

There have been numerous Zelda games released after the original The Legend of Zelda. Many have assumed they never followed a concrete timeline but were sole adventure games of their own. However, this fan theory suggests there is a mythology tying all the games together and that The Legend of Zelda, Zelda II: The Adventures of Link, and Zelda: Breath of the Wild follow each other chronologically. This means Zelda: Breath of the Wild is technical “Zelda III.” Reasons for this include Zelda falling into a deep sleep at the end of Zelda II and Link and Zelda waking from a deep sleep in Breath of the Wild, the old Hyrule destroyed in Breath of the Wild, and the lack of any mention of the Tri-force.

Photo: 25. Gamerscore Blog via flickr. CC BY-SA 2.0, 24. Rob Obsidian & BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0 , 23. Wikipedia Commons.com (Public Domain), 22. BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 21. Wesley Fryer via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 20. Joshua Livingston via flickr. CC BY 2.o, 19. Pexels.com (Public Domain), 18. Wikipedia Commons.com (Public Domain), 17. Wikipedia Commons.com (Public Domain), 16. Wikipeida Commons.com (Public Domain), 15. cocamert via flickr. CC BY 2.o, 14. BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 13. map, Ubisoft – Flickr – map, CC BY 2.0, 12. Precision GFX via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 11. via youtube via youtubecreative commons youtube , 10. Paul Reynolds via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 9. Warvan via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 8. FAN THE FIRE Magazine via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 7. Joshua Livingston via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 6. BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 5. BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0, 4. SobControllers via flickr. CC BY 2.0 , 3. Joseph Nicolia via flickr. CC BY 2.0 , 2. BagoGames via flickr. CC BY 2.0 , 1. Brett Chalupa via flickr. CC BY 2.0